JUNE 15, 2007
VOLUME 4 NO. 11

POLICY & POLITICS

Provincial elections

Healthcare woes topple PEI Tories

Grits' pledge to cure FP shortage welcomed, but expansion of residency program draws criticism


The PEI Liberals swept to power May 28 in one of the most dramatic elections in the tiny province's history. Healthcare issues took centre stage in an election that turned Prince Edward Island's legislature on its head, as the Progressive Conservative majority — firmly in place for 11 years under leader Pat Binns — dropped from a commanding 23 of 27 Legislative Assembly seats to just four, with the Robert Ghiz-led Grits leaping from four seats to 23.

But the new government inherits a province with a troubled healthcare service. The province has been hit hard by a shortage of healthcare professionals, particularly family doctors. The province's Department of Health puts the number of Islanders without a family doctor at 4,000.

Part of the Liberals' phenomenal success may be attributable to Mr Ghiz's most salient campaign promise on healthcare: that every Islander will have a family physician by the end of Mr Ghiz's first term, four years from now.

MORE THAN MONEY
The paucity of physicians, says Dr Scott Cameron, president of the Medical Society of PEI, has been brought on in part by uncompetitive physician recruitment bonuses and has resulted in treatment delays.

To attract new doctors to the province the newly elected Liberals pledged during the campaign to establish a $1.5 million rural doctor recruitment program, which will jump to a total of $4.1 million over the next two years. "Recruitment bonuses are improving but they're not entirely competitive at this point," says Dr Cameron. "There's a lot of competition from Western Canada, but I don't think monetary incentives are the only thing we have to take into consideration. It's the quality of life too," he says. "Physicians would be able to enjoy the lifestyle Prince Edward Island offers if they weren't always so busy."

COMMUNITY CARE
The doctor shortage is taking its toll on the Island's remaining physicians.

For Dr David Stewart, an FP in the small town of Cornwall, the shortage of family physicians is palpable. Since 1991 he's seen 400 new residents arrive in the community and the departure of the only other family physician in the area. "The number of hours I work hasn't gone up, but the intensity sure has," he says. If he goes on vacation, patients in the area must travel to the Queen Elizabeth Hospital in Charlottetown to see a physician. "Community healthcare is very important," he says. "People shouldn't have to travel from our community to get the care they need."

BUILDING ACCESS
Despite the province's health human resources challenges, Pat Binns' incumbent PC government had begun plans before the election to build a centralized hospital in Bloomfield, West Prince, PEI. The plan would have converted the region's O'Leary and Alberton community hospitals into care facilities for seniors.

But the Liberals are unconvinced building a new hospital would solve the healthcare needs of West Prince's rural communities. "PEI has the lowest accessibility to primary healthcare within the Maritime provinces," Liberal chief of staff Chris LeClair explains. "We need to bring more doctors to the community hospitals because care in those areas is below standard for the Maritime region." The Liberal campaign proposed a 30-month moratorium on construction of the new hospital so resources can be directed to the existing community hospitals, and the election victory seems to make the hospital's construction unlikely.

RESIDENCY REBUKE
Mr Ghiz has proposed to expand PEI's family medicine residency program, an idea also brought up by the Tories during the campaign. The promise, however, may not be feasible in light of the ongoing shortage, Dr Cameron says. Additional teaching duties at PEI hospitals, he says, will only reduce the amount of time doctors have to see their patients.

 

 

back to top of page

 

 

 

 
 
© Parkhurst Publishing Privacy Statement
Legal Terms of Use
Site created by Spin Design T.