JANUARY 30, 2007
VOLUME 4 NO. 2

POLICY & POLITICS

Green Healthcare

No incentive for greener hospitals

Doctors speak out against cuts to enviro-friendly healthcare initiative


5 ways to make your practice greener

  1. Start a "green team" to raise awareness and lobby for change
  2. Set a timer to turn down heating by three degrees overnight and turn off computers and lights when the office is closed
  3. Use low-toxicity, low-water cleaning methods
  4. Encourage staffers to use public transportation, carpool, cycle and walk
  5. Create a recycling policy and keep discarded paper to rebind to make scratchpads

There's no question, hospitals are big polluters. From their enormous energy usage to incinerators for biomedical waste to triple-layers of sterile wrapping for disposable medical instruments like syringes, our healthcare institutions leave a mammoth environmental footprint.

Once upon a time, the federal government realized there was a problem and came up with incentives to encourage hospitals to clean up their act. But last March, in a woefully underreported act, the Conservative government pulled the plug on the program.

Called the Energy Innovators Initiative (EII), created by Natural Resources Canada in 1998, the program was devised to provide energy-efficiency retrofit grants of up to $250,000 to Canadian businesses. When it was axed in favour of a new department called EnerGuide for Existing Buildings, the government also took the opportunity to cancel a contract that had been given to the nonprofit Canadian College of Health Services Executives (CCHSE) to act as liaison to the healthcare industry. Over its seven years, that contract garnered environmentally friendly retrofit funding for over 450 healthcare corporations across the country.

Renewable resources

Canadian Association of Physicians for the Environment
www.cape.ca

Canadian Coalition for Green Health Care
www.greenhealthcare.ca

Canadian Centre for Pollution Prevention's Healthcare EnviroNet
www.c2p2online.com

RETROGRADE POLICY
Kent Waddington, a founding member of the Canadian Coalition for Green Health Care, was the coordinator in charge of the erstwhile CCHSE contract. When it was cut in March, he lost the job he'd been doing for seven years. "The program had been extremely successful," he explained. The benefits built on one another: reducing energy expenditure reduced pollution and cut fuel use, which saved money, and that money could then be used for healthcare.

"A lot of people were very concerned when the program was cancelled," he said. "The general consensus among people I speak with in healthcare is that the government is failing to adequately address environmental issues."

This move by the government is in direct opposition to the trend in other countries, notes former Green Party of Canada leader and public health physician Dr Trevor Hancock. In the UK earlier this month, he points out, a £100 million fund was established to help British hospitals reduce emissions and improve energy efficiency in order to combat global warming.

On January 17, the federal government announced a $230 million investment over the next four years in clean energy technologies, including incentives for energy-efficient homes. At press time, the details of the plan still had not been announced but no mention had been made of the healthcare industry.

ONE MAN'S CRUSADE
Dr Jean Zigby, a young family physician from Montreal, is also lamenting the decision to end the contract with CCHSE. "It was unfortunately a shortsighted move on the part of our government," he says. "Energy efficiency is probably the most cost-effective way of reducing our effects on the environment."

Dr Zigby's involvement in the environmentalism movement began about five years ago when he started reading about pollution and global warming. "To my none-too-great surprise, it was as I feared: we are poor stewards of the environment," he says. He discovered, for instance, that Canadian hospitals can be up to six times as polluting as their Scandinavian counterparts. "It doesn't make sense that physicians who are first and foremost supposed to not be causing harm, are actually causing a lot of harm with support of a dangerous healthcare system."

Dr Zigby's discomfort with the environmental impact of his profession grew to the point that in late 2002 he decided to take a sabbatical from his practice in downtown Montreal to figure out how to make his community's clinics greener. "I said to myself, let's see what one physician can do."

What he has accomplished since has propelled him to national renown as a champion of green healthcare, and earned him a Canadian Environmental Award in 2006. Now vice-president of Canadian Association of Physicians for the Environment (CAPE), Dr Zigby has been the engine behind phenomenal changes at his clinic. For instance, he and his colleagues now own five bicycles they use to make home-care visits. He has also exerted enormous influence in helping other Quebec healthcare facilities diminish their environmental impact by designing a guidebook on waste reduction, recycling, reducing energy consumption, among other things. The cuts to the CCHSE contract affected him directly: his clinic received grants from EII in the past.

Doctors interested in green healthcare, says Dr Zigby, should establish a "green team" at their hospitals or clinics to raise awareness among staff and community members. "Be vocal and speak out about your concerns," he says.

"People look up to physicians," says Mr Waddington. "If they are seen as leading the charge on environmental issues, others may well follow."

 

 

back to top of page

 

 

 

 
 
© Parkhurst Publishing Privacy Statement
Legal Terms of Use
Site created by Spin Design T.