JANUARY 30, 2007
VOLUME 4 NO. 2

PATIENTS & PRACTICE

Celebrities say the darnedest things

UK charity wants stars to quit handing out bunk science advice


"Just 10 days of a strict vegetarian diet, wheatgrass juice and placing garlic poultices on my wound (Owwww!) and I was healed," enthused Heather Mills McCartney in the London Evening Standard in 2005. After the motorcycle accident that cost her her leg, the former model suffered a serious infection. The now-estranged wife of Sir Paul McCartney jetted over to an alternative medicine centre in Florida where healers took her off all her meds.

Depending on your point of view, you might think this is just the usual wacky shenanigans of celebs with more money than sense. But some think public figures like Lady Heather are actually endangering people's lives by spouting bad medical advice hither and yon.

A UK-based charity called Sense About Science has decided to fight fire with fire. The organization has printed a pamphlet and opened a hotline to help celebrities avoid propagating false claims about health and medicine.

"If it sounds too good to be true, it usually is," reads the pamphlet. The message is, just because pop star Kylie Minogue tried chromotherapy for her cancer, that doesn't mean it works. Likewise cupping for pain relief (Gwyneth Paltrow), strawberry leaves for swollen ankles (British first lady Cherie Blair) or crystal therapy to sort out the body's natural frequency (Richard Gere).

The scientists involved with the project — over 1,400 of them — would rather spend a little of their time explaining something over the phone than have to undo untold damage caused by celebrity rumour and innuendo, the organization's director told the BBC.

CANADIAN CELEBS
Canada has seen a similar amount of celebrity vacuity when it comes to health matters. In 1988, a 31-year-old patient of Ontario GP Dr Stanley Bernstein died of cardiac arrhythmia eight days after beginning the Dr Bernstein Diet, which recommends a low-carb regimen of just 850-950 calories a day, zero exercise and several vitamin B shots per week. A lawsuit against Dr Bernstein was settled for $700,000. Canadian late-night talk show host Mike Bullard had endorsed the diet and even appeared in advertisements for it. A CBC investigation later found the diet actually recommended eating food that amounted to fewer than half of the calories Dr Bernstein claimed it did.

WOULD YOU TAKE MEDICAL ADVICE FROM THESE PEOPLE?

Tom Cruise, actor and Scientologist

"These drugs are dangerous," said Mr Cruise, referring to fellow celeb Brooke Shields' use of antidepressants for postnatal depression. "There is no such thing as a chemical imbalance." He has also called psychiatry a "pseudoscience."

Prince Charles, future king of England

The Prince of Wales has urged doctors to consi-der the Gerson Therapy to treat cancer. The late Dr Gerson recommended replacing chemotherapy with 13 glasses daily of fruit juice, vitamin injections, and coffee and chamomile enemas.

Robert F Kennedy Jr, lawyer and environmentalist

When Kennedys speak, people listen. That was certainly the case when Bobby Kennedy's son Robert claimed in Rolling Stone/Salon.com that not only does the mercury-based vaccine preservative thimerasol cause autism, but that the US government had tried to cover it up.

Heather Mills McCartney, former model

The zealous animal rights campaigner is probably best known as the soon-to-be ex wife of Beatle Sir Paul McCartney. Her big health worry is milk. "The fact that those kids who drink the most milk gain the most weight should cause alarm bells to be ringing everywhere," said Lady Heather, disagreeing with scientific evidence. "It isn't and milk is still being pushed as essential for children." Lady Heather has also written to the UK Department of Health to demand milk be removed from schools because it causes cancer.

 

 

 

 

 

back to top of page

 

 

 

 
 
© Parkhurst Publishing Privacy Statement
Legal Terms of Use
Site created by Spin Design T. (514) 995-4398