JUNE 30, 2006
VOLUME 3 NO. 12

POLICY & POLITICS

New legislation sparks controversy

Alberta gives pharmacists the power
to write scripts. Are MDs ready?


Alberta pharmacists soon will be able to write scripts for schedule 1 meds, renew existing prescriptions and administer vaccines. It all starts this fall under the Pharmacists Profession Regulation Act. "The legislation is largely structured around relationships," says Greg Eberhart, registrar of the Alberta College of Pharmacists (ACP). "The first thing to explicitly say is what pharmacists can't do: prescribe controlled substances, like opiates and barbiturates. The legislation isn't limiting with respect to other drugs but it is limiting to the circumstances and the framework with which a pharmacist may choose to prescribe a drug." Alberta is the first province to pass this kind of law and it hasn't been without controversy. Many physicians are uneasy with the expanded scope of practice bestowed upon their druggist colleagues. "I don't agree with pharmacists prescribing and renewing meds without the input of the attending MDs," says Dr David Yue, an Edmonton FP.

The president of the Alberta Medical Association (AMA), Dr Tzu-Kuang Lee, agrees. "Well, obviously there are good things but there are also questions regarding a move like this," he says. Those questions include, who would be responsible for letting the physician know a drug has been prescribed or changed and how soon; who is responsible for the patient in the event of adverse side effects; how the physician would find out the reason why a prescription has been changed; and who is ultimately responsible for the patient.

The ACP has been working together with the College of Physicians and Surgeons of Alberta (CPSA) to address physicians' reservations. Not everything has been ironed out. "We are supportive of the collaborative aspects of the plan and with the elements allowing pharmacists to renew prescriptions," says Dr Bryan Ward, deputy registrar of the CPSA. "We didn't support pharmacists having the authority to initiate new prescriptions. We think that in order to prescribe you need to be able to diagnose — and we don't think pharmacists are qualified."

A NEW SCOPE
But pharmacists are already prescribing in a certain sense, counters Mr Eberhart, be it recommending OTC meds, adjusting dosages or referring patients to doctors. With this new legislation pharmacists will be allowed to adapt the prescription to the patients' needs — that means adjusting the dosage, dealing with interchangeability — and to give short-term extensions. Those who do opt to 'really' prescribe — ie initiate treatment — will be put on a clinical register and have to prove they can do the job proficiently. "Those pharmacists are going to have to demonstrate to our college that they have fulfilled requirements that are prescribed by our council so that we can ensure that they have the appropriate training, experience and relationships to perform those functions competently," he says.

Pharmacists who do write scripts will have to work within their scope of practice and not dole out drugs beyond the limitations of their competencies. The prescribing will also have to focus on the needs of patients. They're not looking to be doctors, assures Mr Eberhart. "The purpose of this [legislation] isn't for pharmacists to take on roles to assess and treat conditions beyond that which they're not already trained to assess," he adds.

A perfect example Mr Eberhart points to is heartburn, something that pharmacists see on a daily basis. Right now pharmacists have two options: refer the patient to a doctor or suggest an over-the-counter drug. "[With the new regulation] all of a sudden pharmacists will be allowed to prescribe proton pump inhibitors, which are the drugs of choice. They can prescribe it and provide the appropriate monitoring," says Mr Eberhart.

WHAT ABOUT THE DIAGNOSIS
And it's in the monitoring where some doctors' greatest fears lie. "The new regulation states that pharmacists can prescribe but will not diagnose," says Dr Hani Hadi, a Calgary pediatrician. "This is counterintuitive: prescribing medications implies that a clinical assessment has been made." Dr Hadi's main misgivings are that pharmacists don't have the time or diagnostic background to get a full clinical history and physical exam. "My fear is that this may consequently lead to the inappropriate prescribing of medication," he says.

Dr Lee takes this one step further. "Prescribing is only one link and trying to do it in isolation may be problematic," he says, and fears that the legislation might incite behaviour that may not be conducive to good health.

Mr Eberhart acknowledges physicians' concerns about initiating new prescriptions. "I think right now we're seeing a lot of questions because there is uncertainty about what this [law] means," he says. The key to this legislation remains teamwork. "It's about meeting the needs of the patient in a highly collaborative environment where we respect relationships with other health professionals and where we respect the expertise of the pharmacist," he says.

 

 

back to top of page

 

 

 

 
 
© Parkhurst Publishing Privacy Statement
Legal Terms of Use
Site created by Spin Design T.