APRIL 30, 2006
VOLUME 3 NO. 8

POLICY & POLITICS

MD political hopefuls' big health ideas

Quebec doc goes for federal Liberal leadership; Alberta MD hopes to fill Ralph Klein's shoes. Both would revamp health system



Dr Lyle Oberg

Who: Dr Clifford Blais
Party: Liberal Party of Canada
Backgrounder: Montreal GP Clifford Blais has a formidable goal. The 49-year-old wants nothing short of the Liberal Party of Canada's top job. And though his name may not be as well known as the likes of Michael Ignatieff, Stéphane Dion and Ken Dryden, the good doctor believes he has what it takes to cure the country's medical and constitutional ailments. "Stephen Harper is why I'm running," says Dr Blais. "I looked at his ego and the way he has done things and I decided that I had to run."

During the last election, Dr Blais worked as a volunteer on Paul Martin's campaign. He saw Mr Harper's victory — and Mr Martin's subsequent departure as the chief Liberal — as a danger to Canada. He says Mr Harper has dangerously regressive views on issues like women's rights and gay marriage. "I don't want to come back to the debates we had in the 70s," he says.

DR BLAIS' PLAN
In terms of healthcare, Dr Blais says it's time to allow for more privatization. He believes it will help keep doctors in Canada, free up the public system of perpetual backlog and let doctors make better use of OR times. "I know doctors who are basically begging for operating time, and they can't get it," says Dr Blais. "Hospitals could easily rent their facilities during the off-hours."

He also wants to tackle the Canada Health Act. "In Canada, we basically have a communist medical system, with only one provider. When that only provider cannot provide all the necessary services to its clients in a timely manner, we have a problem. As it is, the system is barely holding together."

As for the country's constitutional woes, Dr Blais, a firm believer in provincial rights, offers the following tonic: the Liberals need only stick to federal matters as laid out in confederation. A former member of the Parti Québécois, Dr Blais says his sovereigntist credentials have helped him understand how Canada can properly work. "The Liberals have to stop saying that Canada needs a strong Ottawa," he says. "I understand the importance of provincial rights. My home is Quebec, but my country is Canada."

Who: Dr Lyle Oberg
Party: Progressive Conservative Association of Alberta
Backgrounder: Dr Lyle Oberg, a Brooks, AB, family doctor, has spent the last 13 years in the trenches of provincial politics. The 46-year-old physician has held three cabinet-level positions within Ralph Klein's government since taking office in 1993. He had a very public falling out with Mr Klein last month after he openly challenged his leadership. He was suspended from the party and now sits as an independent.

Following King Ralph's announcement he's stepping down, Dr Oberg declared his intention to run for leadership of the province's Tory party and spearhead what he considers to be a crucial step in Alberta's history: the introduction of private medical care in the province.

DR OBERG'S PLAN
Dr Oberg believes the current health system is mired in bureaucracy and politics, and thinks healthcare mandarins cling to a romantic (and untenable) idea of socialized medicine. As an antidote, Dr Oberg suggests what might be termed 'the Quebec model' of limited private care anchored by a strong public system. He would also remodel the management-heavy bureaucracy so that doctors and nurses would have more input into how the system is run. "It's not just a question of throwing money at the problem, it's a question of better care," Dr Oberg says. "If I want to have a knee replacement next Friday, because I'll have a week off to recover, I should be able to pay for that service."

Dr Oberg would see to it that doctors fulfill a minimum number of hours in the public system — as is the case in countries like France and Germany. He also wants to bone up the province's treatment of chronic diseases, so that patients don't further burden the public system with complications from not being properly treated in the first place.

 

 

back to top of page

 

 

 

 
 
© Parkhurst Publishing Privacy Statement
Legal Terms of Use
Site created by Spin Design T.