DECEMBER 15, 2004
VOLUME 1 NO. 23
 

Smitherman talks tough in face of doctor dissent


In the aftermath of Ontario doctors' stinging rebuke to the Ontario Medical Association (OMA)-brokered agreement with the province, it looks like the folks at Queen's Park are losing patience. A long and bitter dispute, which saw the OMA membership reject a four-year tentative agreement worth $6.9 billion over four years, came to an explosive denouement on November 26 when the Ontario government presented a revamped take-it-or-leave-it offer to the province's physicians.

Health Minister George Smitherman says he's through negotiating and is eager to implement the new, revised deal, which he claims addresses the major concerns of the disenchanted docs.

WHAT'S ON THE TABLE
The basic premise of the government's deal was to change the way primary healthcare should be delivered, using an incentive-based method of payment for doctors. The contract was to provide incentives such as fee increases of up to 35% for physicians who moved to underserviced areas, for those who chose to specialize in demand areas like cardiac and cancer, and to doctors who worked in multidisciplinary group practices designed to serve more patients.

The OMA was concerned about the lack of incentives for older doctors and solo practitioners, who work on the traditional fee-for-service basis, as well as physician retention and patient waiting times.

One important concession in the new deal is that the government will scrap a controversial $50 million bonus for doctors conditional upon them saving $200 million by prescribing fewer prescriptions to seniors, the disabled and welfare recipients. Doctors will still get this money, but there will be no strings attached.

The other significant bone of contention was the proposed $30 million reassessment study of the deal after two years. That idea was thrown out, and the money will be injected into doctors' raises immediately. Additionally, the plan will lift fee caps for five medical procedures that have long waiting lists: cardiac care, cancer surgery, hip and knee replacements, cataract surgery and MRI/CT scans.

OMA President Dr John Rapin said they needed more time to examine the new deal, which he said is a little short on details. He ruled out a physician strike as consequence of the fiat, but admitted a work-to-rule option is being considered. A mostly-conciliatory Mr Smitherman took the opportunity to restate his willingness to impose the deal if the OMA's membership refuses it again.

 

 

back to top of page

 

 

 

 
 
© Parkhurst Publishing Privacy Statement
Legal Terms of Use
Site created by Spin Design T.