SEPTEMBER 23, 2004
VOLUME 1 NO. 17
 

Crying over spilt milk

Sputtering at the sight of public breastfeeding

Some would like to relegate nursing mums to the prig's sty.
Legislating babes in public arms


When Teresa Pitman sat down to breastfeed her child at an Ontario amusement park some years ago, a security guard soon told her in no uncertain terms to cover up and make herself scarce. "Now, at the same park, I see nursing mothers everywhere," says Ms Pitman, who also happens to be executive director of La Leche League Canada, an international organization that promotes breastfeeding. "It's become a lot more accepted."

AMERICA THE MODEST?
But the issue of breastfeeding in public has once again exposed itself to priggish ire. In August, Illinois joined the two-dozen other states that allow women to breastfeed openly. The debate was brought to the fore by an outraged mother who was kicked out of a gym's day care � for nursing.

Though Canada has no such legislation, there have been some test cases supporting a woman's right to go topless, which can be interpreted to include public nursing. In 1996, the Ontario Court of Appeal ruled that women have an equal right to go topless wherever men do. BC's court has made a similar ruling. Breastfeeding campaigners feel these cases make strong legal precedents for the rest of Canada.

LACTATION EMANCIPATION
But even if it's legal, should mothers be nursing their babies in airplanes and malls? Of course they should, says Dr Peter Nieman, a Calgary pediatrician and father of four breastfed children. "I don't think anyone should be offended by that," he says. "At the same time, mums should be discreet and sensitive to others' wishes." This is especially true in places where people can't walk away from a nursing mother if they're uncomfortable � like in an airplane. If there's a scene, it will likely cause stress to both the mother and baby.

POOR DINING AMBIENCE
For mums who decide that breastfeeding in public is a good idea for them and junior, there's still the matter of whether to stay in a restaurant seating area, for example, or go to the washroom to nurse. Dr Nieman doesn't think washrooms are the best choice. "Twenty minutes breastfeeding in a washroom, even if it's clean, is still a long time in a small space where there could be poor circulation," he says. "With all the people going in and out, the risk of droplet infection is increased." In addition, he points out that "not all people wash their hands, so contact infection risk is also high."

Some public buildings have solved the problem by including designated feeding rooms. Dr Nieman thinks they're a great idea. "Even though they're still in a fairly enclosed space, at least they're not toilet areas," he says. "Breastfeeding should definitely be kept in mind when architects are planning buildings."

 

 

back to top of page

 

 

 

 
 
© Parkhurst Publishing Privacy Statement
Legal Terms of Use
Site created by Spin Design T.